# Repeat axis lines on facet panels

#### Stefan McKinnon Edwards sme@iysik.com

#### 2025-09-04

Deprecation notice: The `facet_rep_wrap` and `facet_rep_lab` have been deprecated in lemon v. 0.5.1. Instead, we refer to the similar solutions in ggh4x’ `facet_wrap2` and `facet_grid2`.

ggplot2 offers the fantastic option for displaying complex data in forms of ‘many multiple’, i.e. the facets. From the example of `facet_grid`:

    p <- ggplot(mpg, aes(displ, cty)) + geom_point()
    p + facet_grid(drv ~ cyl) + theme_bw()

Faceting works quite well in its default form. When the panel’s borders are drawn, nothing lacks.

In the above example, the panel’s borders are drawn with the default settings of `theme_bw()`.

If we desire the axis lines, such as those given in this package, the distinction of the panels disappears.

    library(lemon)
    p <- p + coord_capped_cart(bottom='both', left='both') +
      theme_bw() + theme(panel.border=element_blank(), axis.line=element_line())
    p + facet_grid(drv ~ cyl)

The optimised axis lines are gone from inner panels.

The above example is re-created below with both left- and bottom-axis lines repeated.

    library(ggh4x)

    ##
    ## Attaching package: 'ggh4x'

    ## The following objects are masked from 'package:lemon':
    ##
    ##     GeomPointPath, geom_pointpath

    p + facet_grid2(drv ~ cyl, axes = TRUE, remove_labels = TRUE) +
      coord_capped_cart(bottom='both', left='both') +
      theme_bw() + theme(panel.border=element_blank(), axis.line=element_line())

    ## Coordinate system already present.
    ## ℹ Adding new coordinate system, which will replace the existing one.

Axis lines are repeated across all panels by using `facet_rep_grid` of the `lemon` package.

## Keeping (some) labels

In the following example, we change the facet from a grid to being wrapped on the interaction of `drv` and `cyl`, and add free scaling on y-axis. `facet_wrap` would normally print the y-axis tick labels for each panel, but still ignores the x-axis.

    p + facet_wrap(~ interaction(cyl, drv), scales='free_y')

`facet_wrap` keeps y-axis label ticks with `scales='free_y'`.

A work around by keeping both axes free scale, and fixing the x-axis with either `scale_x_continuous` or limits in `cord_*`, but the same x-axis tick labels are repeated. And this is a bit tedious.

    p + facet_wrap(~ interaction(cyl, drv), scales='free') +
      coord_capped_cart(bottom='both', left='both', xlim=c(2,7))

    ## Coordinate system already present.
    ## ℹ Adding new coordinate system, which will replace the existing one.

X-axis is entirely fixed, and the plot is littered with x-axis tick labels.

We can specify which inner labels to keep with `facet_rap2(..., remove_labels)` . The default is to keep all labels, but we can specify to remove all “x” or all “y”.

    p + facet_wrap2(~ interaction(cyl, drv), scales = 'free_y', axes = TRUE, remove_labels = "x")

With `repeat.tick.labels` we are free to specify which sides to keep.

## Examples

There are many possibilities. Examples given below (but not executed), and they might not be pretty.

    p + facet_wrap2(~ interaction(cyl, drv), scales = 'free_y', axes = TRUE, remove_labels = FALSE)
    p + facet_wrap2(~ interaction(cyl, drv), scales = 'free_y', axes = TRUE, remove_labels = "y")
    p + facet_wrap2(~ interaction(cyl, drv), scales = 'free_y', axes = TRUE, remove_labels = "x")
    p + scale_x_continuous(sec.axis = dup_axis()) +
      facet_wrap2(~ interaction(cyl, drv), scales = 'free_y', axes = TRUE, remove_labels = FALSE)

## Translating between lemon’s and ggh4x’ facets

lemon | ggh4x
--- | ---
`facet_rep_wrap(...)` | `facet_wrap2(...)`
`facet_rep_grid(...)` | `facet_grid2(...)`
`repeat.tick.labels` | `remove_labels,` only “none”, `FALSE`, “x”, “y”, “all” or `TRUE`
(None) | `axes`, only “margin”, `FALSE`, “x”, “y”, “all” or `TRUE`